We offer free shipping in the US & EU* Learn More

August 10, 2020 5 min read

There's nothing quite like cheesy, creamy comfort food to make a bad day a lot better, and there's nothing quite like our cheesy, creamy chicken spaghetti casserole if you're looking for the ultimate comfort food!

A spaghetti pie casserole will quickly take you to foodie paradise, with its delightful mix of creamy cheese sauce, hearty chicken breasts, and soft spaghetti. It's a dish that's guaranteed to win dinner when you're serving it up for the family. The kids will be running back for seconds, so make sure you have enough to go around.

It's easy to make too, you can follow our homemade pasta making guide to add a touch of home comfort. Here's our cheesy chicken spaghetti casserole recipe!


Spaghetti casserole recipe FAQ

Our creamy, cheesy chicken spaghetti casserole recipe is as simple as that, but it's guaranteed to go down incredibly well at the dinner table!

In case you had a few further questions, we decided to put together this quick FAQ to answer the questions we most often hear about this recipe.

Should I make homemade pasta or use dried pasta?

We love using our pasta maker to whip up delicious homemade spaghetti. It's much more wholesome, and once you've perfected the recipe, it's so much tastier than anything you could buy at the store too. By making your own spaghetti at home, you know exactly what ingredients are going into your food! You're able to steer clear of any unnecessary and harmful additives.

But, we get it, you need a bit of time and the right ingredients before you can start cranking out streams of spaghetti. It's definitely a skill that's worth learning and a skill that's going to impress, but if you're short on time, then dried store-bought pasta will work just as well.

Do I need to use a casserole dish?

For starters, casserole dishes are usually non-stick and easy to clean, which makes the cleanup process much smoother. But they also help to give the casserole an even application of heat to keep everything cooking thoroughly to the middle of the dish.

However, we're always making casseroles in dishes and pans that aren't, technically, casserole dishes. If you haven't got a casserole dish on hand, then you can use the same skillet you were sauteeing and mixing the ingredients in, as long as it's oven-proof. You can also use any other types of skillets or pans, just so long as they can safely cook inside a hot oven!

What can I do with leftover spaghetti casserole?

Okay, so we're very doubtful that there will be any hint leftovers. Once the kids taste a bite of this creamy comfort food, they won't want to stop!

But, in the seriously unlikely event that there are some leftovers, you can safely reheat them at a later date. We recommend transferring the spaghetti casserole into a resealable container and storing it in the fridge. This casserole is best eaten or frozen within 48 hours of being cooked.

When you're ready to reheat, simply place the casserole dish back into the oven, or put it into a skillet and gently heat it through on the stovetop.

You can also blast it in the microwave if you're in a hurry, but you'll lose much of the flavor and remaining freshness!

Can I freeze spaghetti chicken casserole?

If you're not planning on finishing the casserole within a few days, then you can place the leftovers in the freezer for up to 6 months. Be sure to stick any leftovers in the freezer within 48 hours of cooking.

Spaghetti casserole will freeze well, keeping much of the taste and flavor, as long as you store it in a ziplock bag or similar resealable container.

When you're ready to eat spaghetti casserole again, allow the leftovers to thaw on the side. When it's defrosted, you can slowly reheat the casserole in a skillet on low heat. This ensures that it's been adequately heated through again before you serve it. You could also warm the casserole in the oven, with an extra layer of grated cheese to add some freshness to the dish.

If you're in a hurry, then you can defrost the leftovers in the microwave, as long as you keep it on low power. Nuking it on high will likely burn the outer edges before the middle can begin to defrost.

What cheese can I use in the recipe?

Our cheeses of choice are cheddar cheese for the sauce and Monterrey Jack for the topping. This dish is all about the cheese, so don't be afraid to go a little wild with the amount of cheese you use (this is comfort food, after all!)

The type of cheese you use can vary, though, and you can happily use any cheese that melts easily for the sauce. Spaghetti casserole with cream cheese is wonderfully creamy, while spaghetti casserole with mozzarella is wonderfully decadent!

Do I have to use chicken in my spaghetti casserole?

Not at all, if you don't have chicken in the fridge, then you can use other meats too. You could slice up sausages, or even use ground beef. White meats work really well in keeping with the flavor, so pork chunks are a good shout. Ham and bacon are simply delicious as well!

Just make sure the meat you do use is cooked through before adding it to the combined mixture.

Can I make a veggie spaghetti casserole?

Of course, you can easily and quickly make this into a vegetarian spaghetti casserole. Remove the chicken breast from the recipe and add a few extra veggies if you like!

Everything else is already veggie, but you can replace the chicken with other vegetables to make the dish more filling. Quorn pieces work well as a chicken substitute, or you can simply cook more mushrooms and bell peppers, or throw in a zucchini, cauliflower, or broccoli to the mix.

Unfortunately, it's a little more challenging to make this dish vegan, as the basis of the casserole is cheese, milk, and creamy soup. If you have vegan substitutes for these - vegan cheese and oat milk, for instance - then you can give it a try!

What can I serve with spaghetti casserole?

Spaghetti chicken casserole is a fantastic dish to serve on its own, especially if you have enough servings to go around.

Given the amount of cheese involved, though, a nice little salad wouldn't go amiss to help even out the ingredients, and add a few more nutrients!

Spaghetti casserole takeaways

That's a deliciously tasty wrap for our cheesy, creamy, chicken spaghetti casserole recipe! Put the fun back into dinnertime, with this fantastically addictive spaghetti recipe that's guaranteed to keep the family wanting more next week, Why not bookmark our spaghetti casserole recipe for next time?

We have more recipes for spaghetti lovers: check our spaghetti pie, taco spaghetti, and spaghetti salad recipe.

Videos from internet:

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in Recipes

3 Spooky Halloween Party Recipes for Your Cast Iron Skillet
3 Spooky Halloween Party Recipes for Your Cast Iron Skillet

October 27, 2021 4 min read

 Using just one cast-iron skillet and a little magic potion, we have three recipes that are going to impress all of your Halloween party guests!
Read More
Pasta Puttanesca: How to Make This Anchovy Spaghetti
Pasta Puttanesca: How to Make This Anchovy Spaghetti

June 16, 2021 4 min read

Read More
Broccoli Pasta Loaded With Cheesy Goodness!
Broccoli Pasta Loaded With Cheesy Goodness!

June 15, 2021 4 min read

Read More
Shopping Cart